Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.


Meet Amy

Compass Founding Bainbridge Island Broker, Amy McFarland is the local expert on everything Island life. As a Bainbridge resident and active member of the community, Amy values relationships, home, and family, making sure every experience with her clients is one they will remember. Voted Top 5 Best Real Estate Agents on Bainbridge Island 2021 and 2022-Amy is known for going above and beyond to provide her clients top-notch concierge-level service.Specializing in Bainbridge Island and the surrounding neighborhoods, Amy works every day with Buyers and Sellers in all price ranges throughout the Kitsap Peninsula.
Beyond the world of traditional real estate, Amy has extensive knowledge of the luxury waterfront market, investment properties, and relocation. She is an intuitive businessperson and able to manage the expectations of her clients with the highest levels of personal attention, efficiency, and sharp business acumen. Amy's business on Bainbridge has been built on referrals, which is a testament to the loyalty and trust that she establishes with her clients.
With over 20 years of sales and experience, Amy has worked for high-end hotels, pharmaceuticals, and now real estate. Her continued success has come from her strong work ethic, outstanding communication skills, genuine passion for people, market knowledge, and strategic execution. She takes great pride in providing her clients with top-notch concierge-level service.
As a Pacific Northwest native who marvels every day at all the Northwest has to offer, she has a seasoned knowledge of the diverse neighborhoods and an appreciation of what makes each of them unique. Real estate is Amy's passion and she considers it a privilege to assist her clients make one of the largest financial investments of their lives.

Outside of real estate, Amy’s favorite thing to do is spend time with her family which includes her husband Casey, daughter Stella (10), and daughter Zoe (7). Amy loves anything outdoors and in her downtime, you will find her golfing, boating, hiking, and entertaining family and friends.

Ledridge Family
Jenson Family
Kim T.
Haley B.
Correll Family
Sara K.
Harmony S.
Halle F.
Jenny M.
Amelia B.
Lindsay S.
Cori H.
Ryan N.
Ryan D.
Liat B.
Pamela J.
Mason Family

Amy is great to work with. Extremely responsive to my so many questions and very knowledgeable about the house-buying process. Thoroughly enjoyed working with her would recommend her highly.

— Ledridge Family


Amy was delightful to work with! She was very knowledgeable about Bainbridge Island and all of the things you want to know before buying a home and relocating your family. She is responsive, knows her stuff, and is a joy to work with.

— Jenson Family


Amazing Amy! She helped us purchase. a new home while we were in another state. Very knowledgeable and wrote an ironclad purchase agreement which we ended up being very grateful for. A transaction that could have taken a turn for the worse without her brains and persistence. We highly recommend her.

— Kim T.


We can’t thank Amy and her team enough for their diligence and hard work in helping us make our first home purchase. Our family was new to the area, so having someone as knowledgeable as Amy helping us out and giving us the ins and outs of the island was crucial to making the right decision. Thank you, Amy!

— Haley B.


Having never purchased a house my wife and I were a bit nervous and not sure how everything worked. After working with Amy we immediately felt comfortable and we were able to find the perfect house for our family. Amy is knowledgeable, polite, and very easygoing. I highly recommend her for your next home purchase.

— Correll Family


I cannot recommend Amy enough for your BI House buying needs. Amy knows the market inside and out, she is aware of listings before they go on the market, she knows how to structure offers to close quickly but most importantly she's a lovely person who takes a lot of stress out of this extremely stressful situation. Thank you Amy for helping us find our dream home!

— Sara K.


In this market we knew we needed someone with exceptional communication skills and a deep personal understanding of what it takes to buy and sell in the Bainbridge Island market. Amy went above and beyond in the process of selling as well as finding and securing our dream home. In this sometimes exhausting market you need someone who knows how to make it work and that is Amy!

— Harmony S.


Amy and her team are by far the best real estate agents we have ever worked with. We moved from out of state and she and her team ensured we understood the market on Bainbridge Island, showed us countless homes, and guided us when putting in offers. I highly recommend using Amy and her team to help you find your perfect house, they truly will exceed your expectations and find you the right spot.

— Halle F.


We had to move fast to get our house ready to sell and we could not have done it without Amy. She is the perfect combination of caring and taking care of business. There were a few repairs and touch-ups and she took charge and coordinated everything so that we could just focus on packing. She went above and beyond and made selling and moving a much more pleasant experience. Amy is the best and we love her!

— Jenny M.


We couldn't be happier with Amy. We are so glad we had her on our team in our search for a home on Bainbridge. Amy works hard, knows how to navigate the market and is fun to look at houses with. After closing, Amy went above and beyond to help us find a preschool, a house cleaner, landscapers, interior help - you name it, Amy will help you. She genuinely wants to make sure her clients are happy during an...

— Amelia B.


Amy is simply the best. We were working through the sale of our home in Seattle and a purchase of a home on Bainbridge simultaneously during a pandemic and unprecedented low real estate inventory on the island. Nothing like that for a little stress! Amy worked tirelessly, she was responsive, incredibly helpful, and encouraging, and worked so hard to make sure that we made it into a home that was right fo...

— Lindsay S.


Amy is such a joy to work with! From day one I felt like she just “got us” and what we were looking for. She was patient, not pressuring us in any direction but giving us time to move at our own pace. When we were ready to view homes, we worked closely with Sean, executive client manager for Amy, and he was amazing! Together, Amy and Sean made this experience stress-free and comfortable. Now that we have...

— Cori H.


Amy is a fantastic person and real estate agent. I’ve had the privilege of working with her personally and professionally for a while now and she knows her stuff, is fun to be around, and is always acting with her client's best interests in mind. She was able to help our family navigate a quick sale on our Bainbridge home while we were in Arizona for a month on vacation and helped us secure the sales pri...

— Ryan N.


Amy and Sean are an amazing team! We had a long search to find our perfect home and they were with us every step of the way. We loved their connection to the community and great relationships with other realtors. They were always open and excited to tour homes with us. And, they were never afraid to share their point of view on a home, its condition or worth - we greatly appreciated their open candor. Wh...

— Ryan D.


Best realtor on Bainbridge Island. Period. Was looking for a home for over 3 years. Amy was patient, helpful, and willing to go out of her way to see properties near and far. She is direct and has no BS in her style so you never feel she is trying to push you into a property that isn’t right. She is honest and unlike many of the other realtors we encountered and had to work with, she has very high integr...

— Liat B.


Amy McFarland is phenomenal! We highly recommend Amy, without reservation. Amy was crucial to our recent purchase of a home on Bainbridge Island. In addition to her thorough and impressive knowledge of Bainbridge Island, its real estate market, communities, neighborhoods, coastal and land use specifics, Amy is extremely professional, responsive, and a committed, loyal advocate for us and all of her clien...

— Pamela J.


Amy helped me and my wife buy a lovely beach house in Port Ludlow over the summer. We had been looking for a vacation home for the past few years but could never find the right combination of location, amenities, and price. When we found this house we knew the timeline would be tight (offers were being reviewed within 10 days of first seeing it) and there would be multiple offers. Amy provided expert adv...

— Mason Family

Work With Us

The Amy McFarland Team's full-service approach to real estate provides her clients with stellar service, professional advice, and start-to-finish attention to detail. Their goal is to exceed your expectations and make your home-buying or home-selling a painless and enjoyable process!